
Short version:
Don’t talk to anyone about the movie GOD ON TRIAL, and don’t read any reviews until you see this movie for yourself.
And you MUST see this movie.
Long version:
I just spent an hour on the phone with one of my friends (who happens to be an agnostic) discussing a movie I came across by accident last night on PBS – Masterpiece. I missed the first part of the movie, but I was immediately drawn into “God On Trial”, and found the movie to be quite extraordinary. When I was asked, “What’s New?”, I just had to tell my friend about the movie.
In a nutshell, a group of Jews at Auschwitz decide to put God on trial for violating the covenant with Israel. This happens on “selection day” when the camp doctor will decide who will be selected to go to the gas chambers and who will continue working.
As the critics say, the discussion around theological issues is powerful and at times “brutal”. It is all in there. Theodicy, free will, history, tradition. All made very real by the pain, uncertainty, and awfulness of their situation.
I give this movie my highest recommendation. The movie is now on my top ten list. I can’t wait to find or buy the movie and see the beginning. It’s a bit slow in spots while characters are introduced and the trial gets up and running, but the farther through the trial you go, the stronger the movie gets.
You can Google: “God on Trial PBS” and find several reviews but I urge you NOT to read the reviews. It will spoil some of the most wonderful, painful, and poignant moments in the movie. (I posted selections from a couple of reviews below.) Suffice it to say that the critics speak very highly of this movie. This movie is not for the faint of heart. It is not for those who can’t tolerate hard hitting questions about God and religion. “Rote” Christians (who want to be told what to believe) will not like this movie. If you are insecure in your beliefs or if you don’t like theological discussions that deal with life’s painful realities, this movie is not for you. My guess is that most of the people who read this blog would find the movie challenging and moving.
Thinking people (believers, agnostics, and atheists) will find the movie remarkable. As just one example, I am so tempted to write about Lieble’s rebuttal of free will, but I won’t spoil it for you. You need to hear his story in the full emotional context of the drama. Despite Lieble’s rebuttal, I still believe in free will, or “agency” as some call it, but his story is compelling.
If I taught theology (or Hebrew scriptures), I would show GOD ON TRIAL to every class somewhere in mid to late semester. It deals with important questions that every religion and every thinking religious/spiritual person should grapple with.
More info is on the PBS web site.
I would suggest you DON’T read the SYNOPSIS at the PBS web site and let the powerful moments in the movie surprise you. Feel free to read the section on CHARACTERS before watching the movie.
You can watch the movie online, but you will need a fast broadband connection. It will only be available online from Nov 10-16, 2008.
As a historical sidelight, the movie is based on play that is based on a persistent story, probably apocryphal, that a group of prisoners at Auschwitz actually did put God on trial. I’ve been told that Elie Wiesel refers to a similar prison camp trial.
There are RBD lists of books – books so good and so important that you simply must “Read Before Dying”. This is a WBD movie.
I will climb down off my soapbox.
One last thing, just in case you were wondering. As a result of our conversation, my agnostic friend (who never goes to movies with religious themes) wants to see this movie.
Buy the DVD from PBS
(more…)